Shutterstock.com_352023275/gnoparus
6 October 2026Risk Management

‘Polycrisis’ means risk managers must act while options remain: Gallagher

Businesses need dynamic, intelligence-led risk management as overlapping crises shrink the time available to act, Gallagher's Carrier and Howard argue.

Key points:
Businesses managing constant disruption
Annual risk reviews are no longer enough
Risk management must become dynamic 

“Business as usual” is looking very different for large European companies. They are no longer operating between periods of disruption, but through them, as geopolitical tension, trade friction, economic uncertainty, technological change and security threats increasingly overlap.

“The polycrisis is really biting in the West, particularly in Europe,” says Adam Carrier, head of consulting at AnotherDay, a Gallagher company. “Multiple crises are happening at the same time and feeding into one another. We’re seeing that across political, economic, social and technological risks, and obviously from a military and conflict perspective as well.”

Charlie Howard, managing director of crisis management at Gallagher Specialty, feels the challenge is compounded by the way businesses are structured. Companies tend to manage risk through individual sites, functions and reporting lines, while the risks themselves increasingly cut across those boundaries.

Politically, Carrier points to mass migration and the rise of populist parties as adding pressure to the EU’s ability to act collectively when member states are facing very different priorities.

“What matters in Portugal may be very different from what matters in Poland, Italy or Latvia,” he said.

“Business as usual now means being able to manage in a constantly fluctuating external environment.” - Adam Carrier

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine also exposed Europe’s energy dependencies, while businesses are simultaneously having to reconsider their reliance on the US as a trading and security partner and their deep commercial links with China.

Germany captures that complexity particularly well, Carrier said. Chinese manufacturers are challenging German carmakers in electric vehicles, while German companies remain deeply embedded in Chinese manufacturing and supply chains.

“It’s a bit of a Gordian knot. There isn’t a simple answer to how you deal with it.”

Security pressures add another layer, particularly in continental Europe. “The ‘so what?’ for large European businesses is that these are relatively novel challenges compared with what they’ve dealt with over the past 20 years, and they’re having to deal with all of them at the same time rather than one at a time,” Carrier told FERMA Forum Today.

“Business as usual now means being able to manage in a constantly fluctuating external environment.”

‘Analysis paralysis’

That pace of change can quickly make an earlier view of risk obsolete.

“We are almost seeing events stacked on top of each other,” Howard said. “An organisation may have done a review a year ago, but everything has moved on significantly since then. That previous understanding is no longer necessarily the risk or exposure the client is facing today.”

Carrier argued that businesses need a better way of recognising when the risks that matter to them have changed. Risk managers can easily become distracted by whichever conflict or geopolitical flashpoint dominates the news. The better starting point is the organisation itself.

“What do you know about your own organisation? What are the assets you rely on to deliver value to your clients and drive your business?” he asked.

“You don’t need to be able to read the future,” he said. “You just need to identify the key external triggers that should make you think about that risk again.”

“We need to take a much more intelligence-driven, data-driven approach to risk management,” Carrier stated.

More information alone will not solve the problem. He warned against “analysis paralysis”, while Howard said the value lies in making complex information usable.

“Without analysis, it is information, not intelligence,” Carrier said.

“The real value is taking something complex, making it really simple and enabling a decision to be made,” Howard added.

More time to act

Earlier visibility gives management something especially valuable when conditions begin to deteriorate — options.

Carrier calls it “decision space”. When warning signals are still weak, companies have time to examine scenarios, move people or assets, adjust supply chains or revisit risk transfer. As a crisis draws closer, that room to manoeuvre contracts.

“When a crisis event occurs, you effectively have no decision space,” he said. “That is why we see businesses make bad decisions in a crisis. They are shooting from the hip.”

AnotherDay saw the difference with an international manufacturer it began supporting around six months before Russia invaded Ukraine. As Russian forces built up near the border, Carrier’s team developed scenarios around possible escalation and its effect on the business.

He said the company was able to move some assets, reconfigure parts of its supply chain and brief customers before the invasion.

“The more activity and decision-making you can push to the left of the bang, the better it is for your business.”

Preparation also has to assume that some capabilities may disappear in a crisis. Howard highlights communications. Internet, email, messaging platforms and satellite communications cannot always be relied on, leaving local teams to make decisions without immediate support from headquarters.

“If communication is taken away from you, people still know what they are doing,” Howard said.

Room to manoeuvre

“Understand, prepare, respond and recover.” - Charlie Howard

Howard believes risk transfer remains fundamental, but brokers and insurers can increasingly add value earlier, helping clients understand how a changing external environment may affect the business before an exposure becomes a loss.

“From the insurance point of view, insurers are absolutely there to pay claims. But if they can stop something from becoming a claim, we are now in that space where everything is interwoven,” he said.

Carrier also sees scope for underwriting to raise risk management standards. He points to cyber, where requirements such as multi-factor authentication have helped push companies towards stronger controls. Similar scrutiny could be applied to political violence and terrorism.

“The more mature organisations are at identifying and managing these risks, the fewer claims there are overall and the more we move towards a more resilient space as an industry,” Carrier said.

Howard sums up the approach as “understand, prepare, respond and recover”.

If disruption is becoming part of normal operating conditions, risk management cannot remain a periodic exercise tied to the next renewal or board review. It has to keep pace with the environment around the business, giving management enough warning to act while there are still choices available.

Adam Carrier is head of consulting at AnotherDay, a Gallagher company, and can be contacted at Adam.Carrier@another-day.com.

Charles Howard is managing director of crisis management at Gallagher Specialty, and can be contacted at Charles_Howard@ajg.com

For more news from FERMA Forum Today, click here.

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.