Pictured from left: Doug Plenty, Andrew Coutts, Jonathan Hughes, and Kerrigan Procter
17 November 2026InsuranceTim Adler

General insurance needs to transform its business model, says insurance boss

The general insurance industry should fundamentally transform its business model, moving away from asking customers to pay the excess and instead, cover the whole cost, priced accordingly.

So says Andrew Coutts, CEO of South African insurer Hollard Insure, who was taking part in a panel discussion on industry modernisation as part of the two-day Global Insurance Forum held at Lloyd’s of London on Monday, 16 November. 

Other panellists included Jonathan Hughes, chief strategy officer, RGA; and Kerrigan Procter, managing director, corporate pensions solutions, M&G. EY partner Douglas Plenty moderated the discussion. 

Coutts said lots of firms are just using technology to make their businesses faster, cheaper and quicker. “There’s a difference between modernising and transforming,” he said. “We’ve got to start out with a blank sheet of paper and make things better for the customer.”

The core question the panel discussed was whether the industry is using technology to fundamentally change the way it does things, or is it just tinkering around the edges? How much of the modernisation going on is just digitising a legacy process?

Plenty admitted that, in the past, the insurance industry has not been known for moving as fast as it could do when it comes to tech. Plus, according to EY, nearly one-third of all transformation projects fail. 

Coutts took a much wider approach to the question, thinking about insurers’ societal obligations rather than just modernising the tech stack. Instead, insurers need to think bigger. “Rather, we can be partners delivering resilience for society.” 

In this world where everything is changing, principles matter more than ever, Coutts said. “Enduring value for every business comes down to trust, values and principle,” said Coutts. 

“There’s so much change coming,” he warned. “You need to be anchored through volatility in times of change.” 

Hughes agreed that the pace of change is accelerating “and we need to keep up with the way things are changing”. The main thing is to ensure that you have a clear focus when it comes to transformation projects, the RGA chief strategy officer said, and that you’re doing it with the customer in mind.   

The core question for any modernisation project, said Hughes, was deciding where you sit on a line between total centralisation at one end and complete localisation for  clients and others, at the other. 

Procter took a more cautious approach, saying any modernisation programme needs to first define what the end goal is, and then investigate processes before breaking them down into modular steps and familiar chunks.

One issue the panel did agree on was the importance of data hygiene, which said Hughes, insurers need to keep on top of “like flossing your teeth”, he joked. 

“We think that good data is the absolute foundation of everything,” said Hughes.

Coutts also reminded the conference that insurers have a wider social responsibility than just profit, and that will be keenly felt in terms of job losses as AI makes its presence felt when it comes to redundancies. 

“If your business is just doing the same thing with 80% fewer staff, is that better?” he asked rhetorically. On the other hand, Coutts said, “We should not kid ourselves that there will still be a job for every person.”

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.