Casualty sidecars drive growth in alternative reinsurance capital: Howden Capital Markets & Advisory

The insurance-linked securities (ILS) market has been traditionally synonymous with property catastrophe: one-year trades, large tail risk and the potential for high returns or sudden losses. But as natural catastrophe volatility reminds investors of its cyclicality, a quieter shift is under way.

Key points:
Casualty offers long-tail diversification
Investors demand discipline and transparency
Lloyd’s provides structural advantages

Casualty sidecars, once a niche experiment, are emerging as a structural part of the alternative capital landscape.

Mitchell Rosenberg, managing director, co-head global ILS, Howden Capital Markets & Advisory, explained the appeal to Monte Carlo Today: “Longer-tail, diversified liabilities introduce an asset yield component into the transaction economics. That broadens the capital universe available to insurers and reinsurers.”

Unlike property cat, casualty portfolios extend five to seven years, allowing alternative managers to generate steady IRRs (insurance recovery and resolution regime) in the high teens while harvesting investment income.

Rosenberg: "Three structural components are critical: capital efficiency, exit mechanisms and asset management. Lloyd’s has all three.”

Bill Cooper, managing director, Howden Capital Markets & Advisory, added: “The underlying investors are searching for risk-adjusted returns. There’s significant capital flowing into private credit-like markets, driven by life insurers, reinsurers, sovereign wealth funds and pensions, all seeking better risk-adjusted returns than public credit offers.”

Treat casualty sidecars as a novelty, and you miss the bigger asset allocation story, because casualty is not cat: risks are frequency-driven, bespoke and less transparent. As Cooper noted: “The investor base here tends to be larger and more sophisticated.”

That sophistication extends beyond claims and reserving. It requires patience, alignment and transparency. Rosenberg said: “These trades are not for every insurance company. They are for quality underwriters and platforms with disciplined reserving, strong claims management and a history and track record of operating through cycles.”

Lloyd’s: the perfect platform

If casualty sidecars go mainstream, Lloyd’s is an obvious launchpad. Once largely a cat playground, it has in recent years worked to open its doors to third-party capital across a broader range of lines.

Cooper: "Global risk is increasing, and insurance and reinsurance capital alone won’t be enough.” 

According to Howden Capital Markets & Advisory, the advantages of Lloyd’s are clear: capital efficiency providing liquidity and defined exits for long-tail trades; and funds, allowing a broad range of asset classes to support the asset management component.

“Three structural components are critical to these trades: capital efficiency, exit mechanisms and asset management. Lloyd’s has all three features,” Rosenberg stated.

So why are casualty sidecars viable now, when earlier attempts fizzled? Three factors stand out for Rosenberg and Cooper. Collateral innovation has increased comfort with assets backing liabilities. Liquidity solutions, via commutation features, Lloyd’s RITC and legacy providers, offer credible exits. And greater transparency, with disciplined reserving and reporting standards, reassures investors.

Individually these changes might seem minor, but together they have transformed casualty sidecars from theory to executable reality.

Cooper is confident this will not remain niche. “Global risk is increasing, and insurance and reinsurance capital alone won’t be enough. Quality platforms will tap into alternative capital across both short-tail and long-tail lines. Casualty sidecars are part of that future.”

With Lloyd’s infrastructure in place, investors increasingly comfortable with bespoke models and sponsors recognising the value of long-term partnerships, the momentum is clear. But structuring casualty sidecars is challenging. The investor base is demanding, modelling nuanced and reserving discipline must withstand scrutiny.

That is where Howden Capital Markets & Advisory positions itself. Cooper explained: “We have the only full-service investment banking business inside a re/insurance broker. We’ve built a dedicated investor coverage group to find new capital sources, professionalising the way investors access this space and providing advice to issuers and re/insurers.”

The aim is simple: to be the leading adviser and capital connector in a market poised for growth. For reinsurers and MGAs: if your underwriting platform can withstand investor diligence, now is the time to consider casualty sidecars.

For investors: if you are comfortable with private credit, casualty-linked structures deserve attention. The yield, duration and diversification benefits are compelling with the right counterparties.

For both sides, Howden Capital Markets & Advisory wants to be at the table. The casualty sidecar is not just another product but a structural bridge between insurance risk and institutional capital.

It is a parallel asset class in the making that could redefine how long-tail risk is financed. The real question is not if casualty sidecars will scale, but who will own the space when they do.

Mitchell Rosenberg is the managing director and co-head global ILS at Howden Capital Markets & Advisory, He can be contacted at mitchell.rosenberg@howdencma.com

Bill Cooper is a managing director at Howden Capital Markets & Advisory. He can be contacted at bill.cooper@howdencma.com

For more news from Monte Carlo Today, click here.

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.