19 February 2014 Insurance

Insurers could do better post-event: Marsh

Insurers must treat clients as clients and not as part of their own portfolio, according to broker Marsh, commenting on a review of how the industry performed in the aftermath of several recent severe earthquakes.

David Pigot, chairman of Marsh’s global claims, made the comments following the release of The Marsh Risk Management Research: Comparing Claims from Catastrophic Earthquakes, which examines how the insurance industry performed in the aftermath of three major earthquakes in Chile, Japan and New Zealand over 13 months between February 2010 and March 2011.

“Marsh’s research reveals that there are reassuring similarities in how insurers interpreted and applied the policy language in each of the events, which offers clients added confidence in their insurance provision and its application in future losses,” said Pigot.

“However, for those negotiating settlements on their clients’ behalf, the challenge is to get insurers to treat a client as a client, and not as part of their portfolio. There is some concern surrounding the strategic portfolio implications of insurers’ decision-making, which makes them mindful about setting a precedent on other claims resulting from the same earthquake or other earthquake-related claims.”

Marsh reports that most claims filed by its clients in Chile were settled within 12 months, and the majority within 18 months in Japan. In New Zealand there are still many outstanding claims, due to practical issues such as the closure of the central business district, on-going earthquake-related activity and practical difficulties in assessing the scope and nature of damage, which is reflected across the industry. However, 16 percent of claims were closed after 12 months, and 32 percent after 18 months.

While Chile achieved the quickest claim settlement rate, the country did not experience the same degree of urban impact and restriction zones as New Zealand or Japan. Although Japan is often associated with earthquake risk, even with its prior experience, the nation was not prepared for the full extent of the earthquake, tsunami, and radioactive contamination.

“The total insured loss from the earthquakes in Chile, Japan and New Zealand is currently estimated in the region of $60 billion. Regardless of how we measure these events, they were truly devastating for the communities and businesses involved. It is heartening to report that the insurance industry stepped up and played its role in enabling the recovery process,” said Pigot.

Already registered?

Login to your account

To request a FREE 2-week trial subscription, please signup.
NOTE - this can take up to 48hrs to be approved.

Two Weeks Free Trial

For multi-user price options, or to check if your company has an existing subscription that we can add you to for FREE, please email Elliot Field at efield@newtonmedia.co.uk or Adrian Tapping at atapping@newtonmedia.co.uk